12 Best Roof Replacement Companies in Toledo, Ohio

If you’re searching for a reliable roof replacement companies in Toledo, you already know how overwhelming the options can be. Toledo’s weather puts roofs through a lot, and when the time comes for a full replacement, choosing the right contractor makes all the difference. This guide breaks down the 12 best roof replacement companies in Toledo, Ohio, to help you make a confident, informed decision.

What to Look for in a Roof Replacement Contractor in Toledo

Before diving into the list, here’s what separates a truly great roofing contractor from an average one:

Certifications and manufacturer credentials are a strong indicator of quality. Companies that earn designations like Owens Corning Platinum Preferred have demonstrated consistent excellence that most contractors never achieve.

Local experience matters. Toledo’s freeze-thaw cycles, lake-effect precipitation, and seasonal storms demand a roofer who knows the local climate.

Warranties, licensing, and BBB standing should be non-negotiable when vetting any roof replacement company in Toledo, Ohio.

Transparent pricing is another hallmark of a reputable roof replacement contractor in Toledo. You should receive a detailed written estimate before any work begins.

The 12 Best Roof Replacement Companies in Toledo, Ohio

1. Pro Craft Home Products

The Most Trusted Roof Replacement Company in Toledo, OH

When it comes to Toledo roof replacement, Pro Craft Home Products stands in a class of its own. Founded in 1952, this family-owned Toledo roofing company has been protecting Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan homes for over 70 years, a track record that very few contractors in the region can match.

Pro Craft is a CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster, a designation awarded to less than 1% of roofing contractors in the entire country. This elite status means homeowners get access to the strongest manufacturer-backed warranties available, including extended coverage that standard contractors simply cannot offer.

Their award shelf speaks for itself. Pro Craft has earned the Excellence Award every year from 2019 through 2025, seven consecutive years of recognised excellence in installation quality and customer service. In 2024, they were named one of the top three roofing contractors in Toledo by Top Rated Local, earning a Rating Score of 98.87 out of 100, built from thousands of verified customer reviews across multiple platforms. They have also maintained a BBB A+ rating for over 70 years, one of the longest-standing accreditations of any home improvement company in the Toledo area.

Pro Craft has installed more than 10,000 roofs across the region and offers a full suite of exterior services, including roofing, siding installation, windows, gutters, and blown-in insulation. Their phones are answered 24/7, making them a dependable choice for emergency roof repair and storm damage situations. Flexible financing options are also available for homeowners who need them.

If you want the most awarded, most experienced roof replacement company in Toledo, Ohio, the choice is clear.

2. Roofing419 – Toledo Roofing Company

Roofing419 is a family-owned, locally operated roofing company in Toledo, Ohio, that has spent over 10 years building one of the strongest reputations in residential roofing across Lucas County and Northwest Ohio. They are not a national franchise with a Toledo satellite office. They are a Toledo roofing company built here, operating here, and accountable here.

CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster:

• Fewer than 1% of roofing contractors in North America qualify for this certification
• Requires strict installation standards, continuous insurance coverage, and a clean project track record
• Allows Roofing419 to offer the CertainTeed System Warranty covering both materials and workmanship

Manufacturer Certifications:

• CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster for asphalt shingle roofing, renewed annually
• Roser Certified Installer for metal roofing, unlocking the full 50-year Roser manufacturer warranty
• Decra Partner in Quality Award for consistent installation standards on Decra stone-coated metal roofing

Awards and Recognition:

• Best of Toledo Award 2017
• Marketplace Ethics Award 2016 and 2023
• Top 3 Roofing Contractors in Toledo Ohio 2025
• Ohio Top Rated Local Roofing Contractor 2025

Project Guarantees:

• Financing available for qualifying projects
• Permits pulled on every full roof replacement
• Every job is backed by both a workmanship warranty and a manufacturer’s materials warranty

3. Tri-State Windows, Siding and Roofing

Tri-State Windows, Siding and Roofing is a locally grown Toledo contractor with a strong emphasis on putting the customer fully at ease from first contact through project completion. Serving Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan, they offer roof replacement alongside siding, windows, and gutter services. Their no-pressure approach and fair pricing on every estimate have built them a loyal following among Toledo homeowners who value straightforward, honest service.

4. Ohio Roofing and Siding

Ohio Roofing and Siding is a fully licensed, bonded, and insured Toledo contractor offering roof replacement alongside exterior siding services. Based locally in Toledo, they bring a straightforward approach to every project with free comprehensive estimates and no-pressure consultations. Homeowners who want a reliable local roof replacement contractor in Toledo that handles both roofing and siding in one place will find Ohio Roofing and Siding a practical and dependable option.

5. SMR HomePros

SMR HomePros is a locally owned and operated contractor serving Toledo and the broader Northwest Ohio region. They handle roof replacement along with siding and window projects, using premium materials suited for Ohio’s demanding seasonal conditions. Homeowners appreciate their attentiveness and the quality of follow-through from estimate to completion.

6. Blue Line Roofing

Founded in 1964, Blue Line Roofing is one of Toledo’s longest-established roofing companies, with over six decades of serving residential and commercial customers across the area. They specialize in fiberglass, flat, and tear-off roof installations and replacements. Their long history in the Toledo market speaks to a consistent standard of workmanship and a reliable reputation built over generations of local homeowners.

7. Mills Siding and Roofing

Mills Siding and Roofing is one of the most reviewed roofing companies serving the Toledo area, with over 1,500 verified Google reviews and a 4.8-star average rating. They are both GAF certified and a CertainTeed ShingleMaster, giving them access to top-tier materials and manufacturer warranties for residential and commercial roof replacement. Their 20-point inspection process, storm damage expertise, and insurance claim assistance make them especially useful for homeowners navigating weather-related roof replacement in Toledo.

8. Roszman Roofing

Roszman Roofing is a long-standing name in Northwest Ohio’s roofing industry. Their longevity in the market reflects consistent performance and reliable customer service. They are particularly well regarded for accurate estimates and projects completed on time and within budget, qualities that matter greatly in roof replacement.

9. Gillette Roofing

Gillette Roofing is a family-owned roofing contractor based in Holland, Ohio, serving Toledo and the broader Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan region since 1980. With over 45 years of continuous operation, they bring a depth of local experience that very few roofing companies in the area can match. They specialize in shingle roof replacement, flat roofs, and repair services, and are known for quick, friendly communication, free estimates, and flexible financing options. Homeowners across Lucas County have trusted Gillette for decades, and the reviews consistently reflect that loyalty.

10. ModForce Home Solutions

ModForce Home Solutions is a Toledo-area roofing and exterior contractor that has been earning strong reviews from local homeowners for their professional sales process, quality installations, and competitive pricing. Customers frequently highlight the responsiveness of their team and the high standard of the finished work. For homeowners looking for a modern, customer-focused roof replacement experience in Toledo, ModForce is a name worth considering.

11. Victors Roofing

Victors Roofing takes an educational approach, helping homeowners understand their material options and the full replacement process before work begins. They focus on building long-term customer relationships and are well-suited to homeowners who want to feel fully informed throughout their roof replacement project.

12. Toledo Home Exteriors

Toledo Home Exteriors rounds out this list as a dependable local option for roof replacement toledo oh. They offer competitive pricing on asphalt shingle systems and bring strong local knowledge to every project. Homeowners on a tighter budget who still want professional workmanship will find them worth considering.

How Much Does Toledo Roof Replacement Cost?

Toledo roof replacement costs typically range between $8,000 and $20,000 for a standard residential home. Several factors influence your final price, including the size and pitch of your roof, the materials you select, whether structural repairs are needed, and the complexity of the job.

Architectural asphalt shingles remain the most popular and cost-effective choice for most Toledo homeowners, while metal roofing carries a higher upfront cost but offers superior longevity. Getting two or three quotes from reputable roof replacement companies in Toledo, Ohio is always a smart move before committing.

How to Choose the Right Roof Replacement Company in Toledo, Ohio

With so many options available, here are the key steps to finding the right fit:

Verify licensing and insurance. Any legitimate roofing replacement toledo oh contractor should carry both general liability insurance and workers’ compensation. Ask for documentation before signing anything.

Check certifications. Manufacturer certifications like Owens Corning Platinum Preferred or GAF Master Elite indicate a contractor who has been trained and vetted to a higher standard.

Ask about warranties. The best roof replacement companies in Toledo, Ohio will offer warranties on both materials and workmanship. Understand what is covered and for how long.

Read reviews on multiple platforms. Google, BBB, and GuildQuality are all valuable sources of verified feedback. Look for patterns across reviews rather than relying on a single platform.

Get everything in writing. A trustworthy roof replacement contractor in Toledo will provide a detailed written estimate before work begins, with no pressure to decide immediately.

Avoid paying in full up front. Reputable Toledo roofers typically require a deposit to schedule the job, with the balance due upon completion.

Final Thoughts

Toledo roof replacement is a significant investment, and choosing the right contractor can mean the difference between a roof that lasts 15 years and one that protects your home for 30 or more. The companies on this list represent the best of what Toledo roof replacement services have to offer, from nationally certified contractors to trusted local specialists.

Pro Craft Home Products leads the list for good reason. With over 70 years in business, back-to-back Excellence Awards, a BBB A+ rating held for decades, and CertainTeed SELECT Shingle Master status, they represent the highest standard of roofing replacement Toledo, OH has to offer. Whether you need a simple shingle replacement or a complete roof system overhaul, Pro Craft delivers quality, reliability, and peace of mind.

Ready to get started? Call Pro Craft Home Products today or request a free quote online to schedule your free inspection.