Top 10 Roofing Contractors in Toledo Ohio

If your roof took a beating this past winter or you just noticed shingles curling in the gutters, finding the right roofing contractor in Toledo Ohio matters a lot. Toledo weather is rough on roofs. Lake Erie wind, spring hail, freeze-thaw cycles all winter. A bad contractor makes all of that worse.

This list covers 10 roofing contractors in Toledo Ohio worth knowing about. Two of them we know well. The rest are pulled from verified reviews, BBB records, and what actual Toledo homeowners are saying online.

1. Pro Craft Home Products — Most Trusted Roofing Company in Toledo Ohio Since 1952

Pro Craft Home Products is the longest-established roofing company in Toledo Ohio. Founded in 1952 and operating continuously from the same Toledo location for over 70 years. That history predates every other roofing company on this list by decades. It is not a marketing claim. It is a verifiable public record that begins before most of Toledo’s current housing stock was built.

Credentials in depth:

Pro Craft Home Products holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status, a designation held by fewer than 1% of roofing contractors in North America. This certification is renewed annually based on actual installation performance, customer satisfaction benchmarks, and continuing education standards. It unlocks the Owens Corning enhanced SureStart Plus warranty covering both materials and workmanship on every asphalt shingle installation in Toledo, including 130 mph wind protection and non-prorated labor and material replacement for the full warranty term. A Toledo roofing contractor that cannot show current Platinum Preferred documentation is offering standard limited warranty coverage regardless of what shingles they install.

Pro Craft Home Products holds Roser Certified Installer status for standing seam metal roofing systems. This certification requires completion of Roser’s technical training program and demonstrated proficiency in metal roof installation. Only Roser Certified contractors can offer the full 50-year Roser manufacturer warranty on standing seam metal roofing in Toledo. Non-certified contractors can purchase Roser panels but cannot unlock that warranty regardless of their experience level. For Toledo homeowners replacing a roof with metal, this certification is the difference between a 50-year backed installation and a contractor-only workmanship warranty.

The Decra Partner in Quality designation reflects consistent installation standards on Decra stone-coated metal roofing systems and unlocks Decra’s 50-year transferable warranty. That warranty stays with the property at resale, which adds verifiable value when a Toledo home changes ownership. For Ottawa Hills homeowners replacing slate with stone-coated metal in a profile that matches the neighborhood’s historic aesthetic, this certification matters directly.

Pro Craft holds these three certifications simultaneously. Roofing419 holds four with the addition of CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster in 2026. The practical difference for most Toledo homeowners is material choice. Pro Craft specializes in Owens Corning and metal roofing systems. If a homeowner specifically wants CertainTeed shingles with the highest tier CertainTeed warranty coverage, Roofing419 is the correct call in Toledo.

Award record in depth:

Pro Craft Home Products earned the Excellence Award every year from 2019 through 2025, seven consecutive years. The Top Rated Local Rating Score of 99.87 out of 100 is built from verified customer reviews across multiple platforms simultaneously, not a single-source rating. The BBB A+ rating has been continuous since 2005, a 20-year uninterrupted record that is the longest continuous A+ rating of any Toledo roofing contractor currently active in the market. Over 10,000 roofs installed across northwest Ohio and southeast Michigan since 1952.

What Pro Craft Home Products does on every Toledo roofing job:

Every roof replacement in Toledo starts with full tear-off down to bare decking. No overlays. Complete decking inspection with photos before any new material is installed. Damaged sections shown to the homeowner with photos and approved before pricing any additional repairs. Ice and water shield installed per Ohio code at every eave, extended through valleys and around every penetration as standard practice. City of Toledo permits or the correct local jurisdiction permit handled on every job. Written workmanship and material warranty on every installation. Pro Craft employees on every job. No subcontractors.

Pro Craft Home Products provides emergency roof repair in Toledo with phones answered 24 hours a day at 419.475.9600. Storm damage documentation with photos is provided the same visit to support insurance claims. Most Ohio policies require storm damage claims within 6 to 12 months of the storm event.

Full service offering in depth:

Pro Craft Home Products is the only contractor on this list that handles the complete exterior of a Toledo home under one roof. Roof replacement, residential roofing, commercial roofing including TPO, EPDM, and flat membrane systems, roof repair, asphalt shingle roofing, metal roofing Toledo Ohio, gutter installation, gutter guards, blown-in attic insulation, vinyl siding, and replacement windows. For Toledo homeowners who need roofing plus gutters, siding, and windows in the same project, Pro Craft handles the full scope without coordinating multiple contractors.

Pro Craft Home Products also provides new construction roofing in Toledo for builders and custom home projects with permit coordination and schedule alignment with the construction timeline.

Service area:

Pro Craft Home Products serves Toledo and all Lucas County neighborhoods, Wood County, Ottawa County, Sandusky County, Putnam County, Henry County, Fulton County, and Williams County in Ohio. Pro Craft also serves Monroe County, Wayne County, Lenawee County, and Hillsdale County in Michigan as a licensed Michigan Maintenance and Alteration contractor.

Best for: Toledo homeowners who want the longest-established roofing contractor in Toledo Ohio with a 70-plus year track record, the only continuous BBB A+ rating since 2005 in this market, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred plus Roser Certified plus Decra Partner in Quality certifications simultaneously, and a full exterior service offering that handles roofing, gutters, insulation, siding, and windows under one contractor. Particularly strong for roof replacement toledo,  metal roofing in Toledo, Ottawa Hills historic homes, commercial roofing, and full exterior replacement projects combining multiple services.

Free estimate: procrafthomeproducts.com/get-a-quote or call 419.475.9600. Phones answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

2. Roofing419 — Best Toledo Roofing Contractor With the Strongest Current Award Record

 

 

Address: 1640 Coining Dr, Toledo, OH 43612 Phone: (419) 509-0456 Website: roofing419.com Founded: 2013 BBB Rating: A+ Certifications: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster, Roser Certified Installer, Decra Partner in Quality Awards: Best of Toledo 2017 through 2025, Marketplace Ethics Award 2016 and 2023, Top 3 Roofing Contractors Toledo Ohio 2025, Ohio Top Rated Local Roofing Contractor 2025

Roofing419 is a family-owned, locally operated roofing company in Toledo Ohio born and built in this city. Over 10 years they have built one of the most decorated award and certification records of any current Toledo roofing company. The Best of Toledo Award from 2017 through 2025 is nine consecutive years of community recognition. That is not a single strong year. It is a sustained nine-year streak of Toledo homeowners voting Roofing419 as one of the best roofing companies in Toledo Ohio. Combined with four simultaneous manufacturer certifications, including the CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster earned in 2026, Roofing419 holds a credential stack that makes them one of the most certified roofing contractors in Toledo Ohio right now.

Credentials in depth:

Roofing419 holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status for 2025, renewed annually based on performance, customer satisfaction, and installation quality benchmarks. Fewer than 1% of roofing contractors in North America hold this designation. It unlocks the Owens Corning System Warranty covering both materials and workmanship on every residential roof replacement completed in Toledo. Annual renewal means the certification is current-year active, not a historical achievement.

In 2026 Roofing419 earned the CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster certification, the highest residential credential CertainTeed awards. This designation is reserved for contractors who meet CertainTeed’s rigorous standards for installation expertise, professional training, and customer satisfaction. As a SELECT ShingleMaster certified contractor, Roofing419 is authorized to offer homeowners the CertainTeed SureStart PLUS extended warranty, a level of protection non-certified Toledo roofing contractors cannot provide. Combined with their Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, Roofing419 is one of the very few Toledo roofing companies holding dual manufacturer certifications from both CertainTeed and Owens Corning simultaneously. That means Toledo homeowners working with Roofing419 have access to premium warranty products from two separate manufacturer systems, giving more material choices and stronger coverage options than any single-certification contractor in the Toledo market.

The Roser Certified Installer designation allows Roofing419 to offer the full 50-year Roser manufacturer warranty on standing seam metal roofing installations in Toledo. Non-certified contractors cannot unlock this warranty regardless of installation quality. The Decra Partner in Quality award reflects consistent installation standards on Decra stone-coated metal roofing and unlocks Decra’s 50-year transferable warranty that stays with the property at resale.

Award record in depth:

Best of Toledo Awards 2017 through 2025 — nine consecutive years. This is the strongest sustained community award record of any Toledo roofing contractor currently active in the market. Marketplace Ethics Award in 2016 and again in 2023, specifically for transparent pricing and ethical business conduct. Receiving it twice across a seven-year gap confirms consistent business practices rather than a single good year. Top 3 Roofing Contractors Toledo Ohio 2025, an independent ranking based on verified customer satisfaction and work quality across hundreds of evaluated Toledo roofing companies. Ohio Top Rated Local Roofing Contractor 2025, based entirely on verified customer ratings across Google, Facebook, and industry review platforms.

What Roofing419 does on every Toledo roofing job:

Roofing419 documents emergency response time as a specific differentiator in the Toledo roofing market. After storm events, emergency roof repair crews arrive within 40 minutes of a call. Every Toledo homeowner receives a written estimate covering materials, labor, and timeline before committing to anything. The sales process is consistently described in reviews as pressure-free and transparent, which is directly consistent with the Marketplace Ethics Award recognition. Storm damage roof repair is documented with emergency protocols and full insurance claim assistance support. Financing options are available for Toledo homeowners who need payment flexibility on a full replacement.

Services: Roof replacement Toledo Ohio, residential roofing Toledo, new roof installation, emergency roof repair Toledo, storm damage roof repair, metal roofing Toledo Ohio, asphalt shingle roofing Toledo.

Free inspection: roofing419.com/free-inspection or call (419) 509-0456.

Best for: Toledo homeowners who want the most certified best roofing contractor in Toledo Ohio right now. Four simultaneous manufacturer certifications including dual CertainTeed and Owens Corning status, nine consecutive Best of Toledo Awards, Marketplace Ethics Award for transparent pricing, and documented 40-minute emergency response after storm events.

3. Westshore Home

Westshore Home is a national contractor that operates in Toledo OH. They handle roof replacement, siding, and windows. They are known for a structured sales process and offer financing. Reviews are mixed. Some customers praise the install quality and others mention a high-pressure sales experience. Worth getting a quote to compare pricing but read the contract carefully before signing.

4. Perrysburg Roofing and Renovation

A smaller local operation serving Toledo and the Perrysburg area. Good reviews on Google for residential roof repairs and smaller replacement jobs. They work fast on single-family homes and respond quickly after storms. Not as much online presence but the reviews from actual customers are solid. Best for homeowners who want a local crew and a simpler process.

5. A.B. Martin Roofing

A.B. Martin has a long track record in the Midwest and does work in the Toledo Ohio market. They handle metal roofing, asphalt shingles, and commercial flat roofing. Strong on commercial jobs. For residential roofing in Toledo OH they are a solid option if you are specifically looking for metal roofing systems. Check their availability since they cover a wide region and scheduling can take longer than a dedicated local Toledo contractor.

6. Five Star Home Improvements

Five Star covers Toledo and surrounding Lucas County. They do roof replacement, siding, and gutters. Reviews on Google average around 4 stars with customers noting the crew is professional and jobs get done on time. Pricing is mid-range. Good option for homeowners who want a company that handles roofing and exterior work together, similar to Pro Craft but smaller in scale.

7. Ohio Metal Roofing

As the name says, this contractor specializes in metal roofing in Toledo Ohio. If metal is specifically what you want, they know the product well. They install standing seam and corrugated metal systems. Less experience with asphalt shingle roofing so if you are comparing material options or want advice on both, you may get a more complete picture from a contractor that does both.

8. Feldkamp Roofing

Feldkamp is a Toledo area roofing contractor that has been around for several years. They do residential roof replacement and repair across Toledo OH. Reviews mention honest estimating and a crew that keeps job sites clean. Smaller operation so projects take a bit more time to schedule during busy storm seasons. Good for straightforward replacement jobs on average-sized Toledo homes.

9. Toledo Roof Pros

Toledo Roof Pros is a newer company in the Toledo Ohio roofing market. They focus on residential roofing, roof repair, and storm damage work. Their Google reviews are positive so far with customers noting quick response times. Because they are newer you won’t find the same volume of long-term customer feedback that more established Toledo roofing contractors have. Worth getting a quote and checking their licensing before hiring.

10. Northwest Ohio Roofing

Northwest Ohio Roofing covers Toledo and the broader Lucas County area. They do residential roofing, repair, and replacement. Average Google reviews, no standout certifications listed publicly. A workable option for basic roofing needs but do your due diligence. Ask about their warranty on labor specifically since that is where smaller contractors in Toledo often fall short.

Roofing Companies Toledo Ohio — Real Cost Data 2026

Toledo roofing companies charge between $8,000 and $20,000 for full residential roof replacements in 2026. The average for a standard home runs $10,000 to $15,000 with Owens Corning architectural shingles. Per square pricing from Toledo roofing contractors runs $350 to $550 for asphalt shingles. Metal roofing runs $800 or more per square.

Pro Craft Home Products pricing: Free written line-item estimate before any commitment. Permits included. Decking repairs documented with photos and approved separately. Call 419.475.9600.

Roofing419 pricing: Written estimate with full breakdown of materials, labor, and timeline. The Marketplace Ethics Award for transparent pricing means their estimates are consistent with what homeowners are charged at completion. Call (419) 509-0456.

Both Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 provide written estimates before any work begins. Never sign with any Toledo roofing company based on a verbal quote.

How to Pick the Right Roofing Contractor in Toledo Ohio

Before you call anyone on this list, here are four things that matter more than price.

Check their certifications. An Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor offers a System Warranty that covers both materials and labor. A standard contractor using Owens Corning shingles cannot offer that. It is a real difference in coverage, not just a logo.

Ask if they pull permits. In Toledo OH, a full roof replacement requires a permit through Lucas County. Any contractor skipping that step creates a liability for you as the homeowner if you ever sell the house.

Look for local track record. Storm chasers show up after every big hail event in Toledo. They do fast work, take the money, and are gone before problems show up. A contractor with verifiable local reviews over multiple years is a safer call.

Get the warranty in writing. Ask specifically what the labor warranty covers and for how long. One year is not enough on a roof. Look for contractors who stand behind their work for at least five years on labor.

If you want to compare the two strongest options on this list side by side, Pro Craft Home Products brings 70 plus years of Toledo roofing history, BBB A+ rating, and a full exterior service lineup. Roofing419 brings Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, Top 3 Toledo contractor ranking for 2025, and a tight focus on residential roofing with strong warranties and a free 19-point inspection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the most trusted roofing contractor in Toledo, Ohio?

Pro Craft Home Products is the most trusted roofing contractor in Toledo, 2026, based on verifiable history and credentials. Founded in 1952, BBB A+ rated since 2005, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, Roser Certified, Decra Partner in Quality, Excellence Award 2019 to 2025, Top Rated Local Score 99.87. Roofing419 is the best Toledo roofing contractor in recent years with the Marketplace Ethics Award twice and Top 3 Roofing Contractors Toledo Ohio 2025. Both are trusted roofing companies in Toledo Ohio with the same manufacturer certifications. Call Pro Craft at 419.475.9600 or Roofing419 at 419.509.0456.

What is the most reliable roofing company in Toledo Ohio?

Both Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 are the most reliable roofing companies in Toledo Ohio based on credentials and verified reviews. Pro Craft has been reliable in this market since 1952 with a BBB A+ record since 2005. Roofing419 has built a reliable 10+ year track record with the Marketplace Ethics Award in 2016 and 2023 for transparent pricing. Both hold Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, Roser Certified, and Decra Partner in Quality certifications. Both use their own crews. Both provide written estimates and written warranties. Call Pro Craft at 419.475.9600 for a free inspection.

What are the best roofing companies in Toledo Ohio?

The best roofing companies in Toledo Ohio based on verifiable credentials are Pro Craft Home Products, Roofing419 – Toledo roofing company. Pro Craft Home Products has the longest history at 70-plus years, the only continuous BBB A+ rating since 2005, and three simultaneous manufacturer certifications. Roofing419 has the strongest current award record including Top 3 Roofing Contractors Toledo Ohio 2025 and Marketplace Ethics Award twice.

How much do Toledo roofing companies charge for a new roof?

Toledo roofing companies charge $8,000 to $20,000 for full residential roof replacements in 2026. The average runs $10,000 to $15,000 with Owens Corning architectural shingles. Metal roofing runs $25,000 to $45,000. Per square pricing runs $350 to $550 for asphalt and $800 or more for metal. Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 both provide written estimates before any work begins. Get at least two written estimates from Toledo roofing contractors covering the same material specification before signing with anyone.

What is the difference between Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 in Toledo?

Both Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 hold Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, Roser Certified, and Decra Partner in Quality certifications and have BBB A+ ratings. Pro Craft has been in Toledo since 1952 with a 70-plus year track record, continuous BBB A+ since 2005, and a full exterior service offering including gutters, insulation, siding, and windows alongside roofing. Roofing419 has been in Toledo since 2012 with a strong 10-year award record including the Marketplace Ethics Award twice and Top 3 Toledo Roofing Contractors 2025. Both are on Coining Drive in Toledo. Call Pro Craft at 419.475.9600 or Roofing419 at 419.509.0456.

Are Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 the best roofing contractors in Toledo?

Yes. Both Pro Craft Home Products and Roofing419 are the best roofing contractors in Toledo Ohio right now. Both have verifiable award and review records that no other Toledo roofing company currently matches as a combination. Pro Craft’s 70-year history and Roofing419’s current award record make them the top two roofing companies in Toledo Ohio for 2026.

What should I look for in a Toledo roofing contractor?

Look for Owens Corning Platinum Preferred or GAF Master Elite certification, verifiable at the manufacturer’s website. A BBB A+ rating with a public complaint history you can read at bbb.org. Own crews on every job rather than subcontractors. Written permit handling on every replacement. A local physical address with a verifiable Toledo operation. Pro Craft Home Products at 419.475.9600 and Roofing419 at 419.509.0456 are the two Toledo roofing contractors that meet all five criteria simultaneously.

Does Pro Craft Home Products serve all of Toledo and northwest Ohio?

Yes. Pro Craft Home Products serves Toledo and all Lucas County neighborhoods, Wood County, Ottawa County, Sandusky County, Putnam County, Henry County, Fulton County, and Williams County in Ohio. Pro Craft also serves Monroe, Wayne, Lenawee, and Hillsdale Counties in Michigan as a licensed Michigan contractor. Call 419.475.9600 for a free inspection anywhere in the service area.